Six Splendid Boutique Hotels in Colorado

Following on from our Unique Places to Stay in Colorado, we have rounded up half a dozen of our favorite boutique properties across the Centennial State.

THE WYMAN HOTEL | SILVERTON

The 15-room Wyman Hotel is a fantastic addition to Silverton’s downtown and gives the small town a welcome alternative for those who may want a dash of modern style while enjoying the town’s more historic aspects. Named for the building it occupies, which was built by businessman Louis Wyman in 1902, the property was thoroughly and expertly renovated and today is a beautiful property with modern furnishings. The Wyman also has a suite that can sleep five, making this a great place for small groups.

THE AMIGO MOTOR LODGE | SALIDA

With 17 rooms and five renovated Airstreams (the latter of which makes Stay Amigo fairly unique among the boutique hotels on our shortlist), Rooms (and Airstreams) at Stay Amigo have modern furnishings with a minimalist design that creates a relaxing environment. The property also has a hot tub, a sun room and fire pits among other amenities. Amigo isn’t a full-service hotel, so while there is generally someone around, you will be pretty much left on your own. Just think of it as a fancy Airbnb.

MELLOW MOON LODGE | DEL NORTE

Built in the early 1940’s as the El Rancho, what would become the Mellow Moon was abandoned for 20 years before it was purchased in 2018. It opened just a year ago as the 10-room boutique hotel. Minutes from the Rio Grande River and on the Continental Divide Trail, Wolf Creek Ski Area and Great Sand Dunes National Park aren’t far away either. There is also a bike shop onsite, a fire-pit to gather around in the evenings and a wood-fired hot tub that is scheduled to be up and running this winter.

THE NIGHTINGALE MOTEL | PAGOSA SPRINGS

Located in the heart of downtown Pagosa Springs, the Nightingale has 17 beautiful guest rooms (including a couple of suites that have kitchenettes) as well as the Neon Mallard cocktail lounge (which recently celebrated its one-year anniversary). The decor and style is meant to evoke the atmosphere of 1950’s roadside motels, which can most obviously be seen in the cool neon sign that tells motorists if there are vacancies or not, the Nightingale has plenty of modern touches, too.

SURF HOTEL & CHATEAU | BUENA VISTA

Sibling properties, the Surf Hotel and Surf Chateau are both on the Arkansas River overlooking the whitewater park in BV’s South Main neighborhood. With 42 guest rooms, the Surf Hotel may push the limits of what a boutique hotel is in terms of size, but it is beautifully appointed yet understated. Located next door and continuing the style of the hotel, the 20 guest-room Surf Chateau has fireplaces, canopy beds, clawfoot tubs, and chandeliers. The Wesley & Rose Lobby Bar serves both properties.

SPOKE & VINE | PALISADE

In the heart of Colorado’s wine country, Spoke & Vine is a 17-room property that is less than 18 months old. With a range of room types, including a full one-bedroom apartment, the property is within walking distance of Palisade’s downtown. With a name like Spoke & Vine, it is no surprise that there is a fleet of cruiser bikes that are available for rent and are perfect for touring wineries. A simple breakfast of locally made granola, Greek yogurt and locally roasted coffee is delivered to your door every morning.

THE WESTERN HOTEL | OURAY 

Originally built in 1891, The Western is one of the few remaining wood-frame hotels in the state. Honoring the building's historic past while adding modern, luxurious touches, the 16-room Western is a gem in the heart of the Uncompahgre Valley. There is a General Store where guests check in and can purchase a variety of miscellaneous goods including a selection of primarily Old World wines. Down a spiral staircase from The General Store is where the spa will eventually be. The other street entrance brings you into The Saloon, where the decor and drinks will once again take you on a journey back in time to when the hotel was first built. The cocktail program is influenced by pre-Prohibition times, with drinks like the Black Manhattan and Mint Julep on the menu. Behind an intimate eight seat chef's counter and visible from The Saloon's street entrance is an open wood-burning cooking fire to beckon folks inside.

Are you enjoying these updates? You can support our ability to find more unique stories to bring to you by signing up to be Patreon of West of 105.